Introduction
Why doesn’t FGBC pass around a collection plate? Pastor Jim Butler and Pastor Cam Porter distinguish giving as an act of worship from the required elements of Lord’s Day worship, and why churches can differ here in good conscience.
Got a question on Christianity, Gospel, Scripture, Theology? Submit your own questions here.
Transcript
Keywords: offering collection, worship elements, Divine Liturgy, regulative principle, visitor pressure, online giving, confessional standards, church practices, Reformed Baptist, worship structure
Speakers: Wim Kerkhoff (host), Pastor Jim Butler, Pastor Cameron Porter
The Question
Wim Kerkhoff: Another regulative-principle question. Is the collection of offerings part of Lord’s Day worship? Why does our church not pass around a bag, a plate, or a box? Isn’t giving part of Lord’s Day worship?
Freedom for Members, Not Pressure on Visitors
Pastor Jim Butler: I’d say yes, I think we should be. We have inconsistencies and idiosyncrasies in things we do simply because that’s what was already in place when I got here, and unless something is broken, you don’t typically try to fix it. But I do think there’s prudence and wisdom in passing the hat, so to speak. I wouldn’t want it to pressure visitors, though. If they want to give, they’re free to, but it’s not a visitor’s place, it’s the members’ responsibility, we look after ourselves. I’ve heard the argument that we should pass the hat so we can get the money, and no, that’s not it. I don’t want to communicate that we’re after people’s money, the way some churches genuinely are. If you want to give, you’re free to, but we’re not going to pressure you or bind your conscience.
Is an E-Transfer an Act of Worship?
Wim Kerkhoff: Today people give online, through bank transfers and technology, so I don’t know how much our deacons are actually counting anymore.
Pastor Jim Butler: The spirit of that question is right, and it wasn’t lost on me: am I worshiping God when I do an e-transfer? If giving is an act of worship, ideally before I hit send I should bless God and thank him for prospering me, but I don’t usually do that, so it does take something away from the worship dimension of giving.
Is Giving an Element of the Divine Liturgy?
Pastor Cam Porter: That gets at an important question: is giving an element of the Divine Liturgy? Confessionally, we can see it’s not included. The reading of Scripture, preaching and hearing the Word, teaching and admonishing one another in psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs, singing with grace in our hearts to the Lord, the administration of baptism and the Lord’s Supper, these are the parts of religious worship to be performed in obedience to God with understanding, faith, reverence, and godly fear, along with solemn humiliation, fastings, and thanksgivings. Those are the elements. So where’s the offering, the passing of the hat or the box? It’s not there. That doesn’t mean it’s not worship, or that it shouldn’t happen on the Lord’s Day. There’s a distinction between what constitutes the Divine Liturgy in the gathering of the church and what the church ought to do, perhaps on the first day of the week, as we have biblical evidence for. Interestingly, those biblical examples are special collections for special relief efforts, not just the general passing of a plate. Confessionally speaking, giving isn’t included as an element of the Divine Liturgy, and I think that says something.
Pastor Jim Butler: So when I e-transfer on a Thursday, I can feel good about it?
Pastor Cam Porter: I think you can.
Charity Toward Churches That Do It Differently
Wim Kerkhoff: There’s definitely been a lot of abuse in churches we’ve seen, compulsion, prosperity preachers with their jets and condos, if you don’t give money.
Pastor Jim Butler: These practical questions are tough to navigate, and good men disagree and differ on them. We need to maintain a spirit of charity. Like with musical instruments, if you’re a confessional Reformed Baptist with a flute and a violin in your church, I’m not going to stay away or pronounce anathemas on you. There’s latitude on things that aren’t as clear as justification by faith alone, which you cannot mess up. I know there are inconsistencies in our own church, and I live with that. My motto now is I’ve got to leave some things for my successors to fix. I don’t want to fix everything, they need something to do too. I think that’s a good posture at this point.
Want more theological Q&A?
Explore the full Ask FGBC archive: https://www.freegrace.ca/ask
Got a question on Christianity, Gospel, Scripture, Theology? Submit your own questions here.







