Whether you’re a member of a Reformed Baptist church, a Presbyterian, Dutch Reformed, or Congregationalist wrestling with questions about baptism, or someone exploring this topic for the first time, this series is for you.
Between November 2024 and January 2025, Pastor Cameron Porter led Free Grace Baptist Church through a study of baptism from Chapters 28 and 29 of the Second London Confession of Faith (1689). These four sessions explain why Reformed Baptists practice credobaptism (believer’s baptism) rather than infant baptism. Each session below includes the recording and a link to its full transcript.
A Word to Our Readers
If you’re firmly convinced of Paedobaptism, genuinely wrestling with questions, or new to this conversation, welcome.
Paedobaptists don’t all hold identical positions. The theological reasoning varies (presumptive regeneration, covenant membership, sacramental grace). Our responses engage covenant-based arguments from Reformed confessions.
We share vast theological convictions with Presbyterian, Dutch Reformed, and Congregationalist brethren. Where we differ on covenant theology and baptism, we express those differences firmly but charitably. The particular Baptists who wrote the 1677 Appendix on Baptism set the tone: “if any of the servants of our Lord Jesus shall, in the spirit of meekness, attempt to convince us of any mistake, either in judgment or practice, we shall diligently ponder his arguments.”
What You’ll Find
Four sessions: (1) what the ordinances are, (2–3) five theological arguments for credobaptism, and (4) responses to six Paedobaptist arguments, followed by questions and answers.
Each session draws from Scripture and from Reformed theologians, including Paedobaptists such as John Owen, whose covenant theology points toward the Baptist position.
Contents
- Session 1: Baptism and the Lord’s Supper (Chapter 28)
- Session 2: Covenant theology and federal headship
- Session 3: Salvation, New Testament clarity, and worship
- Session 4: Six Paedobaptist arguments answered
- Key Takeaways
- Common Questions
- Sources Cited in the Series
- Further Questions and Going Deeper
- Join Us
Session 1: The Foundation – Baptism and the Lord’s Supper (November 24, 2024)
We began with Chapter 28: “Baptism and the Lord’s Supper are ordinances of positive and sovereign institution, appointed by the Lord Jesus, the only lawgiver, to be continued in His church to the end of the world.” Before asking who should be baptized, we need to understand what the ordinances are.
The session first traced the groundwork the Confession lays in earlier chapters (8, 14, 17, 22 and 26), then turned to Chapter 28. The particular Baptists were deliberate in their wording:
- “Ordinance”: they used the word “sacrament” freely in their other writings, but chose “ordinance” here to stress that baptism is a command to be obeyed, and only those who have been regenerated and given faith can obey it.
- No “seal”: the Westminster Confession calls the sacraments “signs and seals.” The 1689 leaves out “seal,” because the seal of the covenant of grace is the Holy Spirit, not water.
- “Positive”: baptism exists only because Christ commanded it by revelation. No church or council may institute, alter or extend it.
The ordinances are means of grace. The ascended Christ, by His Spirit, uses them to strengthen the faith of believers. The power is not in the water, bread or wine. Calvin called them “those living symbols which the Lord has consecrated by his own word.” To neglect them is to neglect the means God has given for our nourishment.
“The seal of the covenant of grace is the regenerating power of the Holy Spirit and the subsequent indwelling of the Holy Spirit that obtains with all who are Christ’s own.”
The session closed with Chapter 28, paragraph 2 and Matthew 28: the ordinances are to be administered only by those “qualified and thereunto called according to the commission of Christ.”
Read the full transcript of Session 1 →
Session 2: The Theology of Reformed Credobaptism, Part 1 (December 8, 2024)
Now we moved into Chapter 29. The central question: who are the proper subjects of baptism?
The particular Baptists understood that this question depends on an earlier one: who are the members of the covenant of grace? That question is the key to the baptism debate. This session made the first two of five arguments for credobaptism.
The Argument from Covenant Theology
Key texts: Genesis 17:7-14, Jeremiah 31:31-34, Hebrews 8:6-13, Romans 9:6-8
Paedobaptists hold that the old and new covenants are one covenant of grace in substance, administered in two ways. The Baptist position, which John Owen (himself a Paedobaptist) also held, is that they differ in substance as well. The old covenant promised land and earthly blessing, came with blessings and cursings, and could be broken. The new covenant promises eternal life, is unconditional because Christ ratified it, and secures the salvation of every member.
Jeremiah 31 describes those members: all have the law written on their hearts, all know the Lord, and all have their sins forgiven. Every member of the new covenant is regenerate. Baptism is the sign of that covenant, so it belongs to those who share in its substance.
“The covenant of grace cannot be administered until it’s ratified.”
Further Study: Covenant Theology
The baptism question turns on covenant theology, and covenant theology raises questions of its own. These recordings from our archive are good places to start. Each has a full transcript.
- A Flyover of Covenant Theology, Jim Butler (10 min)
A short overview that sets covenant theology beside dispensationalism and New Covenant theology, and notes two places where the 1689 differs from the Westminster Confession on the covenants. - A Brief Survey of Covenant Theology, Richard Barcellos (three lectures: Part 1, Part 2, Part 3)
What a divine covenant is, how the new covenant differs from the Mosaic covenant, and why the new covenant was necessary, traced back through Abraham and Adam to God’s eternal purpose. - 2LCF Chapter 7, Of God’s Covenant, Jim Butler (Part 1, Part 2)
A study of the Confession’s chapter on the covenants: the covenants of grace, redemption and works, and why the old covenant is not an administration of the covenant of grace. - The Superiority of the New Covenant, Jim Butler (Hebrews 8)
An exposition of the text at the centre of this argument. The new covenant is unbreakable, writes God’s law on the heart, gives every member saving knowledge of God, and secures full forgiveness. - Who Are the Heirs of the Promise?, Cameron Porter (Galatians 3-4)
Abraham’s physical seed and his spiritual seed. Paul’s answer to who inherits the promises made to Abraham, and what that means for baptism.
For a short answer, see Ask FGBC #22: What Is the New Covenant in the Reformed Baptist View?
The Argument from Federal Headship
Key texts: Romans 5:12-21, 1 Corinthians 15:21-22, 45-49
All humanity is represented either by Adam or by Christ. Baptism signifies union with Christ as covenant head, so it cannot rightly be given to those still under Adam’s headship, including the infants of believers who have not yet been united to Christ by faith.
“We have the covenant maker taking on the form of covenant breakers, so that gloriously, by being the covenant keeper, substitutionarily, and being the covenant curse bearer, substitutionarily, he might bring a multitude of covenant breakers to everlasting salvation.”
Read the full transcript of Session 2 →
Session 3: The Theology of Reformed Credobaptism, Part 2 (December 22, 2024)
We continued the biblical case with the remaining three arguments.
The Argument from the Doctrine of Salvation
Key texts: Romans 6:3-11, Colossians 2:11-12, Galatians 3:26-27
Baptism signifies union with Christ in His death, burial and resurrection. Only those truly united to Christ should receive its sign. This argument also touches particular redemption: Christ is the effectual mediator of every member of the new covenant, so treating unregenerate infants as covenant members implies that some for whom He mediates can be lost.
“There is an inviolable connection between the doctrine of salvation and the doctrine of baptism. Simply, those who are saved by God are such as who are to be baptized.”
The Argument from the Clarity of New Covenant Revelation
Key texts: Hebrews 8:6, 10:1, John 1:17, 2 Corinthians 3:7-18
The new covenant is clearer than the old. Shadows have given way to substance. We baptize on the basis of Christ’s accomplished work, not on the pattern of old covenant shadows.
The Argument from the Doctrine of Worship
Key texts: Matthew 28:18-20, Acts 2:38-41, 8:12, 8:36-38, 16:14-15, 16:30-33
The regulative principle holds that God alone prescribes how He is to be worshipped. Ordinances are to be observed as Christ instituted them, with no additions, subtractions or substitutions. The New Testament pattern is consistent: belief, then baptism. Christ commanded, “make disciples… baptizing them.”
Paedobaptist writers such as John Calvin, John Owen and Matthew Henry defended this principle themselves. Henry wrote that a sacrament must be instituted, and they apply that rule to the Lord’s Supper. Infant baptism has no such command.
“Not only has he not expressly commanded infant sprinkling, but he has expressly commanded the baptism of believers only.”
The session also addressed a common concern. Elect infants who die in infancy are saved by God’s effectual calling, apart from any outward ordinance. That mercy is real, but it is not a warrant to baptize those who have not professed faith.
Read the full transcript of Session 3 →
Session 4: Addressing Paedobaptist Arguments (January 5, 2025)
The final session took up six Paedobaptist arguments. They don’t exhaust the field, and not all Paedobaptists argue the same way (Westminster, Dutch Reformed and Anglican traditions stress different points), but they include the most significant covenant-based arguments. The session drew heavily on Nehemiah Coxe, the seventeenth-century particular Baptist, and on the 1677 Appendix on Baptism.
1. The Abrahamic Promise and the Covenant of Circumcision
Key texts: Genesis 17:1-14, Galatians 3:16, Romans 4:11-12
The argument: God gave Abraham circumcision as the sign of inclusion in the covenant of grace, and infants received it. So infants should receive baptism, the new covenant sign.
Response: Circumcision was never an ordinance of the covenant of grace. It came with blessings and cursings, and it was the foundation on which the church-state of Israel according to the flesh was built, growing into the Mosaic covenant. Before Christ, the covenant of grace was revealed as a promise. It had no ordinances of its own until Christ ratified it in His blood. Abraham had two seeds: a fleshly seed, who received circumcision, and a spiritual seed, the children of faith. Coxe put it this way:
“Abraham is to be considered in a double capacity. He is the father of all true believers, and the father and root of the Israelite nation. God entered into covenant with him for both of these seeds, and since they are formally distinguished from one another, their covenant interest must necessarily be different.” (Nehemiah Coxe)
2. The Inclusion of Children in the Covenant Community
Key texts: Acts 2:39, Deuteronomy 10:16, Philippians 3:2-3
The argument: Children were included in Old Testament Israel, so they should be included in the new covenant community.
Response: The two covenants differ in substance, and the church does not build ordinances on shadows. Even in the Old Testament, outward circumcision pointed to an inward reality, the circumcision of the heart (Deuteronomy 10:16). Paul defines the true circumcision as those “who worship God in the Spirit, rejoice in Christ Jesus, and have no confidence in the flesh” (Philippians 3:3). If baptism replaced circumcision, it would belong to those people.
“The shadow is not also the substance that casts it. The copy is not also the true.”
3. The Transition from Circumcision to Baptism
Key texts: Colossians 2:11-12
The argument: Children were circumcised as a sign of covenant inclusion, so children should be baptized as a sign of covenant inclusion.
Response: Paedobaptists do not carry over circumcision’s own rules. Circumcision was for males on the eighth day; infant baptism is given to boys and girls at any age. The principle is also applied inconsistently. Children ate the Passover under the old covenant, yet most Paedobaptist churches do not give the Lord’s Supper to children before a profession of faith.
4. Christ Welcoming Little Children
Key texts: Matthew 19:13-15, Mark 10:13-16, Luke 18:15-17
The argument: Jesus received and blessed little children, so they belong in the church and should be baptized.
Response: These passages say nothing about baptism. Jesus blessed the children; He did not baptize them. The point is “of such is the kingdom of heaven”: the kingdom belongs to those who receive the truth with childlike humility and openness.
5. The Federal Holiness of Children
Key texts: 1 Corinthians 7:12-14
The argument: Paul says the children of a believing parent are “holy,” so they have a covenant standing that entitles them to baptism.
Response: Even if that holiness is granted, no command to baptize follows from it. Ordinances depend on Christ’s command, not on inferences. The 1677 Appendix on Baptism answered this directly:
“Yet no command for infant baptism does immediately and directly result from such a quality or relation. All instituted worship receives its sanction from the precept.”
The Appendix adds that if birth holiness qualified children for baptism, it would qualify them for the Lord’s Supper as well. And if it had been common apostolic practice to baptize believers’ children, the Corinthians would not have needed to ask whether their children were holy.
6. Household Baptisms
Key texts: Acts 11:14, 16:14-15, 16:30-34, 18:8, 1 Corinthians 1:16, 16:15
The argument: The New Testament records household baptisms, and households contain babies, so babies were baptized.
Response: None of these accounts mentions an infant, and silence cannot prove inclusion. The accounts consistently record hearing, believing and then baptism. The Philippian jailer “rejoiced, having believed in God with all his household” (Acts 16:34). Crispus “believed on the Lord with all his household” (Acts 18:8). The household of Stephanas was “the firstfruits of Achaia” and had “devoted themselves to the ministry of the saints” (1 Corinthians 16:15).
From the Q&A
The second half of the session answered questions from the congregation:
- Should I be baptized if I was sprinkled or baptized as an infant? Yes. We baptize believers by immersion upon a credible profession of faith, including those sprinkled or baptized as infants, and those who were immersed before they truly believed. Baptism does not save, but it is a command Christ gives to believers.
- How do I tell my Paedobaptist family? With grace and patience. Show that the decision is not hasty but comes from conviction from Scripture, and thank them for the care and commitment behind their own practice.
- What about the elders of my Paedobaptist church? Approach them with the same humility, and be well informed about the biblical reasons first. It is right to let your elders know where you stand. It is not your task to convert the church.
- Do I need to take a course or read a book first? The only biblical prerequisite is faith in the Lord Jesus Christ (Acts 8:36-37). The elders do use Christian prudence to see that a profession is credible (Acts 8:18-23).
- Is there a minimum age? No. The particular Baptists looked for doctrinal understanding, evidence of repentance, a willingness to confess Christ publicly, and a sober, thoughtful disposition, judged by what can be expected of a child’s age.
- I was baptized as a believer by sprinkling or pouring. Is that enough? Ordinarily, no. The sign must answer to the thing signified, and immersion pictures death, burial and resurrection with Christ (Chapter 29, paragraph 4).
Read the full transcript of Session 4 →
Key Takeaways
After these four sessions, several core convictions emerge:
- Baptism signifies spiritual realities only believers possess: union with Christ, forgiveness, death to sin, resurrection to new life.
- The new covenant differs substantially from the old: spiritual not physical, eternal not temporal, unconditional not conditional.
- Only new covenant members should receive its sign. Membership is determined by faith in Christ, not physical descent.
- The proper mode is immersion, reflecting burial and resurrection with Christ.
- This flows from our understanding of salvation, covenant theology, the church, and the regulative principle of worship.
- We can differ charitably with Paedobaptist brothers and sisters (Presbyterian, Dutch Reformed, Anglican, Congregationalist) while maintaining these convictions. Where we differ, we do so with mutual respect, recognizing sincere Christians hold varying positions.
Common Questions
Why do Reformed Baptists say “ordinance” instead of “sacrament”?
The particular Baptists used “sacrament” freely in their writings. In the Confession they chose “ordinance” to stress that baptism and the Lord’s Supper are commands of Christ, to be obeyed by those able to obey them, that is, regenerate believers.
Are the old and new covenants the same covenant with different administrations?
No. Following John Owen and the 1689, they differ in substance and not only in their outward rites. The old covenant promised earthly blessing and could be broken. The new covenant promises eternal life, cannot be broken, and secures the salvation of every member (Session 2).
What does Jeremiah 31 teach about who belongs to the new covenant?
Every member has the law written on the heart, knows the Lord, and has received forgiveness of sins (Jeremiah 31:33-34; Hebrews 8:10-12). New covenant membership belongs to the regenerate.
Is baptism the new circumcision?
No. Circumcision was an ordinance for Abraham’s fleshly seed and pointed forward to Christ. Baptism signifies a present union with Christ that only believers have (Session 4; see also Ask FGBC #21).
What happens to infants who die before they can believe?
Elect infants who die in infancy are regenerated and saved by Christ through the Spirit, who works when, where and how He pleases (1689 Confession 10.3). Their salvation does not depend on an outward ordinance (Session 3).
Why immersion rather than sprinkling or pouring?
The sign must answer to the thing signified. Immersion pictures death, burial and resurrection with Christ (Romans 6:3-4), and the Confession calls it “necessary to the due administration of this ordinance” (29.4).
Sources Cited in the Series
- The Second London Baptist Confession of Faith (1677/1689), Chapters 28-29, and its Appendix on Baptism (1677)
- Nehemiah Coxe, A Discourse of the Covenants
- John Tombes
- Pascal Denault, The Distinctiveness of Baptist Covenant Theology
- Fred Malone
- Paedobaptist writers: John Owen, John Calvin, Matthew Henry
Further Questions?
For specific baptism questions, see our Ask FGBC podcast:
- #10: Why Should Only Believers Be Baptized?
- #2: Is Pouring or Sprinkling Sufficient for Baptism?
- #21: Is Baptism in the New Covenant the New Circumcision?
- #22: What Is the New Covenant in the Reformed Baptist View?
- #20: How Can I Explain Credobaptism to a Teenager Who Grew Up Paedobaptist?
- #35: Believer’s Baptism Before Communion?
- #56: When Should a Believer Be Baptized?
- #70: Is Progressive Covenantalism Compatible with the 1689?
Going Deeper
- Baptism in the Old Testament, James M. Renihan (April 5, 2026)
If circumcision is not the Old Testament type of baptism, what is? Renihan argues it is the washings of the old covenant: the consecration of priests, the Day of Atonement, and ritual cleansing. Believers are baptized because they too are priests to God, consecrated for access into His presence. - 2LCF Chapter 28 – Of Baptism and the Lord’s Supper, Cameron Porter (August 2, 2026)
A fresh pass through Chapter 28 that sets the particular Baptist view of the ordinances against both Roman Catholic sacramentalism and Paedobaptist covenant theology, and asks what is lost when Christians neglect them. - 2LCF Chapter 29 – Of Baptism, Cameron Porter (August 30, 2026)
The five arguments from Sessions 2 and 3, condensed into a single study. The Q&A takes up new questions: baptismal regeneration, baptizing “in the name of Jesus only,” and how to regard Paedobaptist believers.
Join Us
If you’re in the Chilliwack area, join us for our ongoing Confession of Faith studies every Sunday morning at 9:30am before worship. We alternate between prayer meetings and consecutive studies through the 1689 Confession.
If you have questions about baptism or are considering believer’s baptism, reach out to Pastor Jim Butler. Whether you’re seeking theological answers, interested in baptism preparation, or wanting to discuss further, we’re here to help.
A Word on Dialogue
We recognize sincere, Bible-believing Christians hold different convictions on baptism. The particular Baptists maintained “it is our duty and concern so far as possible for us, retaining a good conscience toward God, to seek a more entire agreement and reconciliation” with Paedobaptist brethren.
We share that commitment. If you disagree with the Baptist position, we respect that. If you have questions or want respectful dialogue, we welcome it. The church’s health advances not by avoiding difficult conversations, but by pursuing truth together with charity, humility, and mutual respect.
Free Grace Baptist Church is a confessional Reformed Baptist church in Chilliwack, BC, adhering to the 1689 London Baptist Confession of Faith. We exist to glorify God through expository preaching, doctrinal fidelity, and Christ-centered worship. Learn more at www.freegrace.ca







